New Buffalo, MI place to staycozycozy

Search accommodations in New Buffalo, MI

420 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • makemytrip
  • oyo
  • yatra
  • goibibo
  • travelguru
  • cleartrip
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • tripcom
  • agoda
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

420 Lodgings in New Buffalo, MI

Happy Hideaway: Downtown New Buffalo Cottage, Big Fenced Yard, Fire Pit - New Buffalo, MI
9.0 12 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 3
₹39629/nighttotal: ₹79258 (2 )

Happy Hideaway: Downtown New Buffalo Cottage, Big Fenced Yard, Fire Pit

apartment - New Buffalo
This New Buffalo lakeside property is less than 1.6km from New Buffalo City Hall and Lake Michigan, with New Buffalo railway station an 8-minute walk away.
The four-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps six, boasts a fully equipped kitchen, in-house laundry, patio, spa, and parking, offering direct access to Lake Michigan and proximity to New Buffalo Township Public Library and New Buffalo Marina Park.
The Reunion House Tree Tops Flat Unit! - New Buffalo, MI
New Buffalo, MI
4 3
₹100891/nightfor 1 night

The Reunion House Tree Tops Flat Unit!

apartment - Michigan City
This Michigan City flat offers a treetop experience, located 46 kilometres from Deep River Waterpark and 35 kilometres from Valparaiso University: Brauer Museum of Art.
This spacious 209 square metre residence accommodates 21 guests with three bedrooms and two bathrooms, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a terrace, garden, outdoor fireplace, and an on-site water park, with free WiFi provided throughout.
Designer's Own Cozy Cottage - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 117 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 1
₹31028/nighttotal: ₹62056 (2 )

Designer's Own Cozy Cottage

apartment - New Buffalo
This charming one-bedroom apartment is located in New Buffalo, just a short walk from the beach and close to the town centre. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The apartment comfortably accommodates two guests and features a well-equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and parking. Guests can enjoy a relaxing stay in this pet-friendly (with approval) apartment, and can easily access the beach, shops, restaurants, and other attractions in the area.
Lake Life Livin- Beach House - New Buffalo, MI
9.0 2 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
4 3
₹138470/nightfor 1 night

Lake Life Livin- Beach House

apartment - Michigan City
This three-bedroom, three-bathroom holiday home in Michigan City is a 0.4km walk from Lake Michigan and a short drive from Washington Park and its zoo, offering easy access to Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore.
The 272 square metre property sleeps six, includes Wi-Fi, air conditioning, linens, and amenities such as soap and a hairdryer, providing comfortable accommodation for exploring Michigan City's attractions.
Downtown Hideaway - New Buffalo, MI
9.6 112 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹96397/nighttotal: ₹192794 (2 )

Downtown Hideaway

house - New Buffalo
This four-bedroom New Buffalo holiday home, located in the Downtown area, is a 19-minute walk (approximately 1.5km) from New Buffalo Beach and 56km from South Bend Regional Airport.
The 226 square metre property features a fully equipped kitchen, three bathrooms (including a jacuzzi), a patio, free Wi-Fi, and accommodates up to eight guests, with cycling opportunities nearby.
The Reunion House Two Massive Units In One! - New Buffalo, MI
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
4 6
₹203871/nightfor 1 night

The Reunion House Two Massive Units In One!

house - Michigan City
This substantial detached house in Michigan City is situated 46 kilometres from Deep River Waterpark and 35 kilometres from Valparaiso University's Brauer Museum of Art.
This six-bedroom, four-bathroom property offers a generous 427 square metres of living space, accommodating up to 42 guests with amenities including a dishwasher, air conditioning, WiFi, a terrace with an outdoor fireplace and dining area, and a garden, with opportunities for nearby cycling.
Blueberry Hill ~ *We Have Power* - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 52 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
4 2
₹38320/nightfor 1 night

Blueberry Hill ~ *We Have Power*

apartment - Michigan City
This Blueberry Hill cottage near Lake Michigan in Michigan City offers a peaceful, 0.8-km walk to deeded beach access and is 0.8 km from Lake Shore Drive, providing easy access to local attractions.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom holiday home sleeps four, features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a garden, fitness centre, parking, and complimentary ice cream and sodas; enjoy relaxing outdoor spaces on the deck and in the side yard of this 0.2-hectare hilltop property overlooking Blueberry Pond.
River Run Retreat | Gather By The Water - New Buffalo, MI
10 3 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
4 5
₹117248/nightfor 1 night

River Run Retreat | Gather By The Water

apartment - New Buffalo
This riverside flat in New Buffalo offers peaceful river views and direct water access, ideal for group events.
This accommodation sleeps 16 guests and features three bathrooms, air conditioning, internet, a kitchen, and an outdoor fire pit, with pets welcome.
Private Heated Pool, Hot Tub And Beach! - New Buffalo, MI
10 8 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 5
₹303049/nighttotal: ₹606098 (2 )

Private Heated Pool, Hot Tub And Beach!

apartment - New Buffalo
This five-bedroom New Buffalo holiday home is a short walk from a private association beach, offering easy access to the New Buffalo shoreline.
Sleeping up to twelve guests, the property boasts a heated pool (May 1st-September 30th), hot tub, sauna, gas grill, and ample parking for four cars, alongside a fully equipped kitchen and all modern conveniences.
Beautiful Wooded Cabin Short Walk To Lake Michigan - New Buffalo, MI
10 86 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 2
₹44850/nighttotal: ₹89700 (2 )

Beautiful Wooded Cabin Short Walk To Lake Michigan

cabin - Michiana
This 1930s cabin is situated on a wooded acre in Southwest Michigan's Harbor Country, just 80 kilometres from Chicago and a short drive to Indiana Dunes National Park.
The two-bedroom, two-bathroom property sleeps six guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a garden, a fitness centre and a private beach.
Living My Best Life W Private Gordon Beach Access - New Buffalo, MI
9.8 11 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 3
₹167674/nighttotal: ₹335348 (2 )

Living My Best Life W Private Gordon Beach Access

apartment - New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home is situated in Union Pier, a short walk from Gordon Beach on Lake Michigan and close to New Buffalo's amenities and Warren Dunes State Park.
Sleeping up to ten guests, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom property boasts a spacious open-plan living area with vaulted ceilings, two stone fireplaces, a chef's kitchen, and a screened porch, alongside private beach access and proximity to Union Pier's restaurants and breweries.
Hot Tub, Deck & Backyard: Cozy Union Pier House! - New Buffalo, MI
9.5 185 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹46227/nighttotal: ₹92454 (2 )

Hot Tub, Deck & Backyard: Cozy Union Pier House!

house - New Buffalo
This spacious house is situated in Union Pier, just 47 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport and a short drive from New Buffalo's charming downtown. Guests have consistently rated the property excellent for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The property offers 132 square metres of living space and comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests in its four bedrooms. Enjoy relaxing evenings in the private hot tub, prepare meals in the fully equipped kitchen, and unwind in the spacious living area.

Best New Buffalo, MI lodging with a pool

Among the 420 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best ones with a pool

Fun Beach House, Pool, Spa, Steps To Lake Michigan - New Buffalo, MI
9.3 260 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 8
₹41323/nighttotal: ₹82646 (2 )

Fun Beach House, Pool, Spa, Steps To Lake Michigan

apartment - Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
This family-friendly lakeside house is located near the village of Union Pier, just 1.6km from Burnison Galleries and 3.2km from Union Pier Beach. The property has excellent user, location and cleanliness ratings.
The house has 8 bedrooms and is 325 square metres in size. It offers a private pool, a spa tub, a terrace and a garden, as well as a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, and free Wi-Fi.
Cottage In The Woods + Pool, Fishing Pond - New Buffalo, MI
9.8 22 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 2
₹54739/nighttotal: ₹109478 (2 )

Cottage In The Woods + Pool, Fishing Pond

apartment - Grand Beach
This Grand Beach holiday home is situated 1.9km from Whittaker Woods Golf Course and within 4.8km of Grand Beach Marsh and Michiana Beach, offering easy access to Lake Michigan's shores.
The two-bedroom property sleeps four guests and boasts a private pool, balcony, fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, free Wi-Fi, and outdoor BBQ facilities; ideal for families seeking a relaxing beach getaway.
Sandy Shores - New Buffalo, MI
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
2 3
₹58833/nighttotal: ₹117666 (2 )

Sandy Shores

house - New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home, situated in Union Pier, Michigan, is approximately 47 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport and offers convenient proximity to Union Pier's skiing opportunities.
The three-bedroom, two-bathroom property sleeps up to 11 guests and boasts a private pool, free Wi-Fi, free parking, a well-equipped kitchen, and a patio; enjoy relaxing evenings by the fireplace or unwind on the tennis court.
Lake Michigan Adventures - New Buffalo, MI
New Buffalo, MI
2 1
₹40826/nighttotal: ₹81652 (2 )

Lake Michigan Adventures

house - Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
Vacation house to rent. You will be located in Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert.
Facilities and services: a dish washer, a terrace and a fridge. This house in Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert also has air conditioning!

Best family friendly New Buffalo, MI lodging

Among the 420 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best for families

Downtown Nb Cottage, Backyard, Fire Pit, Walkable - New Buffalo, MI
9.2 14 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 2
₹36033/nighttotal: ₹72066 (2 )

Downtown Nb Cottage, Backyard, Fire Pit, Walkable

apartment - New Buffalo
The Pocket Cottage is a three-bedroom property situated in a peaceful New Buffalo neighbourhood, approximately 1.3 kilometres from the beach.
This 61-square-metre holiday home sleeps six, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, smart TVs, a spacious backyard with a fire pit, and offers discounts on local beach equipment rentals.
Lake Michigan Beach Is Across Street, 6 Person Hot Tub, Fire Pit, New Bathrooms - New Buffalo, MI
10 111 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹159571/nighttotal: ₹319142 (2 )

Lake Michigan Beach Is Across Street, 6 Person Hot Tub, Fire Pit, New Bathrooms

apartment - New Buffalo
This family-friendly holiday home is located in Union Pier, just 1.6km from Union Pier Beach and Lake Michigan, with Gordon Beach and Townline Beach also within 1.6km. The property has received excellent guest reviews and offers a peaceful setting close to the beach and other attractions.
This spacious house spans 307 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests. The home features a range of amenities, including a spa tub, an arcade/game room, a garden, gas grills, free WiFi, a fireplace, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard - New Buffalo, MI
9.4 5 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹69386/nighttotal: ₹138772 (2 )

Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard

house - New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home, situated 2.3 kilometres from New Buffalo Beach and 56 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport, offers easy access to Lake Michigan's shores.
The 10-square-metre property boasts a spacious four-bedroom layout sleeping up to 19 guests, complete with a fully equipped kitchen, dishwasher, terrace, garden, bar, parking, air conditioning, and a game room with firepit.
Charming Union Pier Cottage In The Woods - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 36 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 3
₹28597/nighttotal: ₹57194 (2 )

Charming Union Pier Cottage In The Woods

apartment - New Buffalo
Echo Cottage, a three-bedroom holiday home in Union Pier, New Buffalo, is situated a short 3.2-kilometre drive from a public beach and close to Harbor Country's attractions.
This self-catering property sleeps five, boasts a hot tub, outdoor shower, and large deck, plus a well-equipped kitchen, kids' bedroom with play area, and fire pit.

Frequently asked questions about accommodations in New Buffalo, MI

  • How can travelers reach New Buffalo, MI?

    The easiest way to get to New Buffalo is by car, as it's just a short drive from Chicago. You can also fly into the South Bend International Airport, which is about an hour away. If you're looking for a more scenic route, you can take the Amtrak train to New Buffalo, it's a lovely journey through the countryside.
  • What outdoor activities can visitors enjoy in and around New Buffalo, MI?

    New Buffalo is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts! You can swim, sunbathe, and go for a walk on the beautiful beaches of Lake Michigan. There are also plenty of opportunities for hiking and biking in the Warren Dunes State Park, which has over 2,000 acres of sand dunes, forests, and wetlands. And if you're feeling adventurous, you can go kayaking or paddleboarding on the lake.
  • When is the ideal time to plan a trip to New Buffalo, MI?

    Summer is the most popular time to visit New Buffalo, but it can get crowded. If you're looking for a more relaxed experience, you can visit in the shoulder seasons, spring or autumn. The weather is still pleasant, and the crowds are smaller. The fall foliage is especially beautiful in October.
  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in New Buffalo, MI?

    The paved bike path along the lakefront is a great place for a leisurely stroll or bike ride. If you're looking for a more challenging route, you can try the Warren Dunes State Park trails. They wind through the dunes and forests, offering stunning views of Lake Michigan.
  • What nearby towns or cities can be explored from New Buffalo, MI?

    There are a few charming towns within a short drive of New Buffalo, like Three Oaks and Sawyer. If you're looking for a bigger city, you can head to South Bend, Indiana, which is about an hour away. It's a great place to visit for a day trip, with museums, art galleries, and plenty of restaurants and shops.
  • What amenities can travelers expect from accommodations in New Buffalo, MI?

    New Buffalo has a wide range of accommodation options, from budget-friendly motels to luxurious hotels. Many of the accommodations offer amenities like swimming pools, hot tubs, and fitness centres. You can also find places with kitchens and laundry facilities, which are great for families or longer stays.

Popular destinations

Best New Buffalo, MI accommodations with a balcony

Quiet Downtown Home With Hot Tub, Firepit, Washer/dryer - Walk Everywhere - New Buffalo, MI
9.6 36 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹90833/nighttotal: ₹181666 (2 )

Quiet Downtown Home With Hot Tub, Firepit, Washer/dryer - Walk Everywhere

apartment - New Buffalo
This New Buffalo residence is a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom holiday home located on a quiet side street, 805 meters from the town centre's shops and restaurants, and 1.6 kilometers from New Buffalo Beach.
This spacious 226 square meter holiday home accommodates up to 8 guests and features a well-equipped kitchen with two ovens, a private backyard with a hot tub and gas grill, and accessibility features in the primary bedroom and bathrooms.
New Buffalo Home With Private Pool And Hot Tub! - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 37 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹92199/nighttotal: ₹184398 (2 )

New Buffalo Home With Private Pool And Hot Tub!

apartment - New Buffalo
This holiday home is situated just 1.6km from Lake Michigan and a short 15-minute drive from New Buffalo Public Beach and the New Buffalo Railroad Museum, offering easy access to the area's attractions. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This spacious house has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 12 guests. Enjoy the convenience of a private pool, a spa tub, gas grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, along with a washer and dryer, a terrace, and parking.
Close To Town Large Yard Fire Pit Gas Grill Beach 2.5 Blocks - New Buffalo, MI
9.8 63 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹56951/nighttotal: ₹113902 (2 )

Close To Town Large Yard Fire Pit Gas Grill Beach 2.5 Blocks

apartment - New Buffalo
This charming apartment is located just 0.5 kilometres from the beach in Union Pier, a short walk from the bustling downtown area. It consistently receives excellent reviews from guests, highlighting its comfortable and family-friendly atmosphere.
The spacious apartment, spanning 181 square metres, comfortably accommodates up to 11 guests with its four bedrooms and two bathrooms. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden, a terrace, and parking, as well as a host of beach essentials for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
La Luna Lakeshore - Fantastic Lakefront Living In Union Pier - New Buffalo, MI
10 2 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 6
₹154966/nighttotal: ₹309932 (2 )

La Luna Lakeshore - Fantastic Lakefront Living In Union Pier

apartment - New Buffalo
This beachfront apartment in Union Pier, Michigan, offers direct access to Lake Michigan and is situated near Warren Dunes State Park.
This spacious 317 square metre dwelling boasts four bedrooms, five bathrooms, and sleeps eight, featuring a fitness centre, terrace, and modern conveniences including high-speed Wi-Fi and fully equipped kitchens in each room.

Best New Buffalo, MI accommodations with a kitchen

Deer Oak Cottage - Cottage Right By The Lake - New Buffalo, MI
8.8 3 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 2
₹39297/nighttotal: ₹78594 (2 )

Deer Oak Cottage - Cottage Right By The Lake

apartment - New Buffalo
This Union Pier holiday let is situated amongst trees, a brief drive from Townline Public Beach and local attractions such as St. Julian Winery.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom flat accommodates up to eight guests and offers a games room with ping pong, a fire pit, gas grill, and a sunroom, with Townline Public Beach only a short distance away.
Walk 10 Mins To Train & Town, 15 Mins To Lake! - New Buffalo, MI
10 39 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 3
₹41194/nighttotal: ₹82388 (2 )

Walk 10 Mins To Train & Town, 15 Mins To Lake!

apartment - New Buffalo
This New Buffalo train, ideally located in the downtown area, offers easy walking access to the beach, marina, shops, and restaurants, including Bentwood, Stray Dog, and Oink's ice cream.
The three-bedroom, three-bathroom holiday home sleeps seven guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, Weber Genesis gas BBQ, high-speed Wi-Fi, YouTube TV, a large garden with a fire pit, and a washer/dryer.
Bright Beach-community/winter Wonderland Cottage - New Buffalo, MI
9.5 117 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 4
₹36985/nighttotal: ₹73970 (2 )

Bright Beach-community/winter Wonderland Cottage

apartment - Michiana Shores
This charming cottage is situated in a peaceful wooded area in Michiana Shores, just a short walk from the beach and an hour from Chicago. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The cottage offers four bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to five guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious screened porch, two patios with dining tables and chaise lounges, a charcoal grill, a fire pit, and Wi-Fi.
Deer Oak Cottage - New Buffalo, MI
10 4 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
2 2
₹38177/nighttotal: ₹76354 (2 )

Deer Oak Cottage

apartment - New Buffalo
Deer Oak Cottage, a holiday home in Harbor Country, is situated a mere 800 meters from the popular Townline Public Beach and offers convenient access to New Buffalo. This family-friendly property accommodates up to eight guests across two bedrooms and features a fully stocked kitchen, a game room with ping pong, an outdoor fire pit, a koi pond, and inclusive beach gear.
©2026 cozycozy.com